Willow Talks Books 77.8K subscribers · Nov 8, 2024

The Crime Masterpiece That Divided Its Fans

Reviews3

Loved

what pip does in this third book makes so much thematic sense I cannot go into it at all without spoiling it but it is a perfect ending for what pip goes through for the journey that she's taken herself on throughout these books

Liked

now compared to the first book good girl bad blood's mystery element isn't as strong in my opinion a good Girl's Guide to murder is a better crime novel it has a better mystery and that's because it's more of a traditional puzzle you can solve this puzzle before pip us or alongside her as you go in the first novel this one is different she is chasing something and that something isn't overly compelling it's not a puzzle to solve because here is the transition between murder mystery and Thriller in this book pip is solving a crime as it happens she is racing against the clock she is stressed bad things are happening her life is changing around her faith is slowly dropping it's intensely exciting