the devil and the dark water is an absolute masterpiece of cohesive plotting and narrative wonderfully well-rounded characters who drive the plot forward but i also carried along with it helplessly in the waves and waters of this choppy dangerous world and it plays with genre and it plays with plot and it plays with your expectations of what a detective's job is and what their powers are it does everything perfectly this is a perfect novel
Willow Talks Books 77.8K subscribers · Nov 8, 2020
In which I gush about The Devil and the Dark Water
i also put it down halfway to read the midnight library which was a big mistake don't do that
i was very upset when i read the secret commonwealth last year because one of my favorite authors growing up let me down writing a character that he created philip pullman lyra is what i'm talking about


