CONCLUSIVELY ranking the Witcher series

I love it to pieces. I think it was like really fun to slow down with Geralt and Regis and Dandelion on this little journey.

I really liked Blood of Elves. I liked it a lot.

Spinning Silver is like that for me. I will go to bat and die for that book. But at the same time, if you guys remember, I was quite critical of it.

I was going to say whatever the second anthology book was my favorite. I think it works because cohesively the short stories all kind of play into the same theme of Destiny as parenthood essentially and also just it's so emotionally affecting when at the end Siri comes out to hug Geralt and like my little heart goes pitterpatter like that.

I think the reason why I felt let down by Lady of the Lake is that it felt like a betrayal from the author to the reader, which is probably not intentional.

I think what the author is doing is very skillful, but I did not really enjoy it, but at the same time, parts of it are very well written.

I found a lot of those original stories somewhat uneven, which we'll talk about more when we get there. In S or A tier, honestly.

But then that last fourth with Siri in the desert and like reading the is just like it's hard to read and it like it and the unicorn. So put an A.