This story is such a raw and visceral exploration of grief and being haunted by one's past and that draw to fall into the familiar even when it is unhealthy and it's really a powerful read and I think that Clayton really used the fantasy Western setting perfectly within the story that he wanted to tell.
all the books i read in october // reading wrap up
But yeah once again Patricia really knocked it out of the park with this one it's really adorable and if you're looking for a christmy read with a little cozy Nostalgia and also murder thrown in this is the book for you.
The character in this are incredible he does such a great job with the characters the brutality of the world is given the severity and gravity that it deserves and but it never feels gratuitous now that doesn't mean that it is not incredibly brutal because it is but he walks that line so well.
This was an incredible book it's told in third person so he refers to himself as a character and it's just a really vulnerable and honest read and I really appreciated it I thought it was really beautiful so I highly recommend this if you're looking for a good Memoir.
What I was struggling with a lot was that the close emotional invest investment that I had with the characters really took a backseat in this book because there was so much information and economic and political information that was being thrown at me through much of this book.
If you are looking for a middle grade read for your kids or even yourself I think this one is pretty decent there's a lot of really great characters in this book and it's been really fun to read it with him.
I felt like a lot of the emotional impact moments were not earned I felt like we were dropped in at a point where we were just told to have the emotional investment in the relationships and the characters and I never really found that it paid off I wasn't really drawn in by anything and I really had a hard time with the convenience of some things but just the emotional investment really did not feel like it was earned so that was my big issue with this.
I can definitely see why this book is lauded as an excellent piece of Vietnam War fiction it is very well done it is a very heavy read so just if you're going to check it out be aware of that but overall this is a very impactful Stark look at the reality that a lot of these marines faced in Vietnam.







