ToriTalks 17.1K subscribers · Jul 7, 2025

So Many Five Star Reads! Reading Wrap Up with New Favorites

Reviews11

Loved

That was historical fiction. It's one of the best historical fiction books I've ever read, despite the fact that the time period that it takes place in isn't one that I typically gravitate towards. Absolutely loved it.

Loved

There were a few things in this book that I didn't love, but overall, I found this storytelling to be really well done. I thought the characters were incredibly vibrant and real, and the storyline and the kind of underpinning of the larger conflict of this story is so it's magnetizing.

Disliked

I really struggled to get through book two. Really struggled. And a lot of the points that I think I would have enjoyed more and would have captured my interest and attention more as we work through the storyline of book two didn't hit me the way that I wanted them to because I was struggling so much with the writing style and the character work in this book.

Mixed

But I will commend John Williams heavily in this book for writing a story like this as beautifully as he did and being able to keep my attention through the entire story. And yeah, so again, this is not a pickme up book and I do not enjoy it as much as I enjoyed Augustus, nor do I think it is as well written as Augustus was.

Liked

There were some pacing things and especially some character motives that felt a little convenient or rushed, which is always something that pulls me away just a little bit from my immersion and investment in the story. But overall, this is a very fast-paced, very gritty feeling story.

Liked

There's a lot of humor in it that I really appreciated. And without even trying, because Maddie is funny without trying to be funny, just the way that she looks at life and her kind of practical, pragmatic view of the way things should be had me chuckling quite a bit.