The Brothers Gwynne 24.1K subscribers · Dec 13, 2025

Reviewing The Last 30+ Books We Read | Yes, No, Maybe |

Reviews36

Loved

The cast of characters was more diverse, more gripping, more compelling. The pros was far stronger. The plotting was fantastic and the crescendos towards the end of the of this book built up so well and they were such a wide mix of crescendos as well.

Mixed

So, A Dance for Dragons, the ending was fantastic. There were some POV characters added into this book that are actually my favorite of the series, but I think with that really slow and quite tepid start, it made me kind of lack the energy, lack the enjoyment that I've had from the rest of the series. It's definitely the weakest book.

Loved

Really lovely pros, great storytelling, and it is such an original story. PL Stewart is not scared to go against the conventions of fantasy and strike out at New Grounds. This is such a fresh book to read.

Loved

Ned Stark is one of my favorite POV characters of all time, the world is brimming with energy. And although I kind of know Game of Thrones front to back from the series and I have read these before, when I read them this time and that I was binging them back to back, I just fell in love with the world.

Loved

Book one, Ascendant, does a fantastic job of combining kind of classic fantasy with modern fantasy. It's got very nostalgic feel, but then after the kind of first few chapters, it added a dose of nuance and uniqueness that really made it stand out on its own, whilst definitely hearkening back to those more classic stories with more warmth and heart rather than the anti-heroes we are so well acquainted with nowadays.

Mixed

It's very well written and there's a good kind of philosophical lining to the story, but my it is dark. So I probably wouldn't recommend this to anyone unless they want to do a character study and they really want to go through all of Cor McCarthy's works.

Disliked

I really love the slice of life, the combination of characters from the first two installments mixing together at different points in their life. But then it felt very lazy the plot line that is pushed in there of the love story was just really forced not worked out and it was very disappointing to be honest.

Loved

There are quite a few twists in Empire the Damned which were really rewarding. It's not just a twist for the sake of it. It was one that had me invested, really shocked me and changed my perspective of the story and really had me kind of secondguessing what I'd been told by certain characters.

Loved

Fantastic characterization. There is a lot of gritty realism in this series, but it really does contain what the Arththeran is about. The interlink nature of heroism and tragedy, the betrayal, the damage on each other, but above all standing for your friends for loyalty and what is right.

Loved

Fantastic characterization. There is a lot of gritty realism in this series, but it really does contain what the Arththeran is about. The interlink nature of heroism and tragedy, the betrayal, the damage on each other, but above all standing for your friends for loyalty and what is right.

Loved

Because this is a philosophical, mythic, dragon soaked, fiery epic of fantasy and horror and contemporary fiction and exploration of friendship in one of the greatest forms of modern literature. It is quintessential on its own. It is genre bending, genre defying.

Loved

I think James Logan did such a great job of ramping up the tension and the energy in the Blackfire Blade, but not losing where he came from in the Silver Blood Promise. Kind of kept those things that made him a strong writer, a really unique series and just made it even better.

Disliked

The beginning was really good and then she's named after she I know I know but everyone called Edith you can't immediately just assume they're great. And I'm not saying she wasn't a nice person but this decayed into predictability and the themes were so heavy-handed.

Loved

This is a really nice bite-sized example of how strong Richard Swan's writing is. He's got a great understanding of character, of pacing, of really unique dialogue that feels kind of Tarantinoesque at times. It's really gripping.

Loved

Fantastic characterization. There is a lot of gritty realism in this series, but it really does contain what the Arththeran is about. The interlink nature of heroism and tragedy, the betrayal, the damage on each other, but above all standing for your friends for loyalty and what is right.