Talking Story 22.5K subscribers · Feb 23, 2026

Shadows Upon Time EXCEEDED Expectations! - Weekly Reader 2x29

Reviews12

Mixed

Objectively I think this is a very well written book. I think C.S. Friedman is quite the craft person and I think she did something special. I just don't think it came together for me and I've got certain reasons of why it didn't and I can't wait to get to speak to everybody because I could absolutely be missing some things.

Disliked

I feel like this is suffering from for me for me is suffering from a little bit of that blow that event blow. And we're not just telling we're not just telling a story that moves our characters and through the characters moves us. We're telling this grand huge sweeping hyperbolic bust them up and it's like okay.

Loved

And the way that they handle that with each other, and the tension of the relationship comes with their own emotions and how they treat each other that has rippling effects on that supernatural world that they're trying to navigate together is like that just creates some sort of magic that I can't take my eye off of. That like the book is their relationship.