However, the onethat I think is the most notable this year, and this is a hard one cuz Ienjoyed all of them, is going to be Embassy Town by China Miéville.
SciFi that SHOULD Have Won a Hugo || 2000-2020s WUGOS
Of all of theseeligible books, I have to say I think we're going to keep A Deepness in theSky by Vernor Vinge.
I didn't find the resolution to be that innovative orinteresting, but let's look at the candidates.
I think she really did somethinginnovative with the Byzantine Empire there.
This isa reasonable World War II book time travel novel. I don't like that it wasdivided into two by the publisher.
I also really think this book didn't deserve a Hugo. It'smostly magical and it definitely a play to the Hugo fans.
So, I'm definitely going to give Anathem by Neal Stephenson the Hugo thisyear.
However, Ididn't find it as interesting, I'm sad to say. I think I ended up gettingconfused by a lot of the pronouns.
So, I got to be honest, a lot of these books were really fantastic and Ihave read all of them.
I really was surprised by this bookabout how deep it was, and definitely want to give it a Hugo.
This isa reasonable World War II book time travel novel. I don't like that it wasdivided into two by the publisher.
I thinkthis cult classic definitely deserves the Woogo for that ending if nothingelse.
I think that Born issomething really special. It was written a very beautifully and it's very weirdlike all of Jeff VanderMeer's stuff.
Now, I have to say I really liked Cage ofSouls, but it wasn't Tchaikovsky's best work.
Not only is this an enjoyable book, but itreally broadens the scope of what the first book started. And it reallydeepens the characters in this story.
It hadsome really big potential to be one of my top 10 books of all time, except forthat ending, which really bothered me.
We're going toleave Fifth Season and I'm going to also award a double winner Hugo to Childrenof Time.
I had some serious issueswith the end of Death's End. I really did.
But, Dogs of War was the only AdrianTchaikovsky book that made me cry. Like, oh my gosh, talk about tugging on yourheartstrings.
This onewas not just interesting, but it was innovative and enjoyable about the powerof language. I haven't read a book like it and it had very alien aliens.
Now I know that there's a lot of popularity about Empire ofSilence, but I wasn't particularly wowed by that first book and I think that manypeople were not.
Future Home of the Living God by Louise Erdrich, veryinteresting story.
And Golden Son was also a very powerfulsecond book.
Many of you guys know my qualms and angrinessover this book has a lot to do with how very poorly he treated his femalecharacters with rape scenes and unnecessary things.
Now, I know House ofSuns is very popular, however, I didn't love it as much as everyone else seemsto have.
When I officially read it, it was a book that I did not like. And yet,as time has gone on, I have only grown more fond for it, and I think it wasvery representative of the time.
Now, I have to be honest, I have not read Ferryman or Creation Node, andI wasn't super impressed by Infinity Gate or In Ascension.
Now, I have to be honest, I have not read Ferryman or Creation Node, andI wasn't super impressed by Infinity Gate or In Ascension.
This is one of my all-time hatedbooks. I would personally burn this book.
I think I might go ahead and give this award to JumpNuts by Hao Jingfang, because this is a book unlike anything else I've everread.
Now, Ihaven't read Skyward Inn or Cloud Cuckoo Land, but I have to say the other threeare incredible books that all should have won over Desolation Called Peace.
I'm really happy to say that I would behappy with any of these books winning over the one that did.
Let's go with Little Brother by Cory Doctorow, which actually had a lot ofinteresting things to say with privacy.
Iunderstand why they made it into a video game, and I've never seen a book dodarkness as a character in such an incredible way.
I think that The Mountain inthe Sea was one of the best candidates for this year. I still stand by it, andI think that it definitely deserves a Woogle.
Now, I have to sayI don't know that it can just stand alone and be a super great book. It doeshave one of my favorite characters from Novella 2 in it, but I don't think Iwould give it a Woogo.
Ireally want to award it to Ninefox Gambit, which I had an enjoyable time. Ithink it was very new and into innovative for this area.
However, of the books that I have here, and alsoconsidering the no win option, I think I'm going to have to go with Old Man'sWar by John Scalzi.
This post-apocalypticworld very viscerally disturbed me when I was reading it. But sometimes you haveto be uncomfortable to appreciate what a book is doing. This book and the rest ofthe series is very worth reading.
However, I wouldprobably replace Outpost with Calculating Stars because that book wasjust so much fun and it was so much colonization and a little bit of sci-fihorror and I really enjoyed it.
This is afantasy book that she wrote that I absolutely loved.
This book did a lot for the genre, and I feel like it was justan all-time great fun.
PerdidoStreet Station was really something weird and really something special.
However, I do think that ofall three of these books, the one that I think executed things the best andreally did something nice for the genre is definitely Project Hail Mary by AndyWeir, hands down.
This is ahidden gem book that I was really surprised by, but we have to compare itwith what is actually a candidate in this year.
So, I got to be honest, a lot of these books were really fantastic and Ihave read all of them.
While an enjoyable book, I have often been a little bit upset that this book,while being fun, was a winner of a Hugo.
This started anincredible series that I think deserves a Wugo.
Many ofthese are better than The Graveyard Book in my opinion.
I really like Semiosis. I think it was very accessible, but I don'tthink I would replace Calculating Stars with it either.
I'm going to be honest, Seveneves wasawesome, but I know that it had that contentious last little third of thestory.
Now, Ihaven't read Skyward Inn or Cloud Cuckoo Land, but I have to say the other threeare incredible books that all should have won over Desolation Called Peace.
He really outdid himself withShroud. I really enjoyed it.
This is a book that I liked just fine, but it didn't really doanything special for me.
The official winner in 2006 isSpin by Robert Charles Wilson, which I have to say is not one of my favoritebooks.
Although I do have to say, a littleteardrops happened for The Swarm and Algebraist, which are also fantasticbooks.
And I do think that this book was very interesting. I just wasn't wowed by it.
And I didn't really like City and the City.
Collapsing Empire wasone of the more serious books that Scalzi did. And I really think that ifwe're going to give him an award, we need to give him awards for the reallygreat work he did.
I could see Dark Forest winning because itreally was a powerful second book.
Iremember finishing the very end of the book and feeling like she had adrop-the-mic kind of moment where it was a perfectly crafted story, perfectlyplotted, and with an incredible ending.
Many ofthese are better than The Graveyard Book in my opinion.
Hydrogen Sonata, Ian Banks is alwaysgreat. However, it was one of the later books, kind of a harder accessibility.
And I love TheLight Brigade, but I don't think I would replace Memory Called Empire for it.
So, I got to be honest, a lot of these books were really fantastic and Ihave read all of them.
And that's becauseman, there were some great science fiction coming out this year and TheMartian just really led the way for accessible science fiction. And wow,what an excellent book that was.
I'm trying to decide between Mercy of Gods, which isn't everyone's favorite,but I think is going somewhere very interesting for the science fictiongenre.
I loved the optimism in this book, one that really touched me a lot morethan the rest of his books. I really liked Ministry for the Future.
And I'm going to be honest, it wasn't as good as thefirst. So, I have no problem replacing this one.
So, I got to be honest, a lot of these books were really fantastic and Ihave read all of them.
Definitely abook that does something new and interesting.
And it's just like a so uniqueand so different that I really think that it deserves a Hugo.
It was a wonderful wrap-up, but again, Idon't think that it deserved its own Hugo, especially if you read it as anindividual book.
Although I do have to say, a littleteardrops happened for The Swarm and Algebraist, which are also fantasticbooks.
This is definitely a detective fantasy story, which was enjoyable, butalso kind of not for the Hugos.
I do think that I'm goingto leave Windup Girl as a Woogo winner, and I don't think I'm going to give anyof the rest of them a award because I don't think that this needs to be a tie.
I realize that it's very beautifullywritten, but it doesn't really stay in your minds. Didn't really quite enjoyit, but let's see what else we have to work with for our candidates for thisyear.
This is a very notable book and it was one thatI truly did enjoy.
Too Like the Lightning really started anincredible series, but that original first book wasn't the strongest or myfavorite. Although she did reinvent politics in a way that was veryintriguing.
I really liked theTV show based off of Wool, but I thought the first book was a little bit of amess.















































































