SciFiScavenger 14.1K subscribers · Nov 4, 2026

Three 9/10 Books! October's Science Fiction Reading Ranked

Reviews13

Liked

I really liked the cast of time-traveling characters and the growing sense of temporal peril that develops as the book progresses. I felt very vested in Cal and Olivia's relationship, and felt each twist and turn in that, some of them quite significant, quite deeply.

Loved

I enjoyed the reversal of fortune and the way that Lauren continued to scrap for what she needed. And I like too the glimpses of how things seem to turn out via the journal entries of her estranged daughter. I think considered as a pair with Parable of the Sower, I thought this was great.

Liked

The pacing is good, the description of the local ecosystem, the close but never quite compatible nature of the locals versus the stranded humans are all I thought really well done. I liked it and remain keen to read more of her Hainish cycle.

Liked

Like the first book, it's over the top, it's violent, the dialogue is a bit fruity at times and it's even funny in places, but it does have a lot of heart. The Shattered Skies is definitely the middle novel of a trilogy in terms of how it holds up the story and I didn't love it as unreservedly as I did the first book.

Liked

The relationships are done well, I thought. I liked in particular the difficult relationship between Gem and Foss, and I thought that the descriptions of the protectorate and life in the village were done very well, too, if slightly and I expect deliberately odd.

Loved

I like the way that the two Peters and their real and imagined lives seem to merge and the boundaries between what we believe to be real and what we believe to be figments of Peter's imagination blur. It's a delightfully odd, twisting Mobius strip of a book.

Loved

But the chief joy for me in this book was the depth that McAuley puts into the science, the terraforming of these extreme environments. I found that their setting in general to be a very solid and believable.

Liked

I think, , it's very clear that Harrison thought, , extremely deeply and took advice even about how a society of evolved dinosaurs might function, and I thought it was fascinating, , to read from that perspective. A very rich view of both the Ilani and Tanu society, , is built, and we get, , to care very much, , about the characters that we meet, of both kinds.