Just today, I was talking about how Bruce Freriedman, who challenged this book, also challenged a beloved middle-grade book called Amari and the Night Brothers, which I loved. I gave it to my kids and to my nieces.
Reads with Rachel 122K subscribers · Dec 8, 2025
The Goodreads Awards show us everything wrong in publishing
I'm disappointed to see that Onyx Storm is in there because that even disappointed a lot of FourthWing fans. It drew out the story further in a way that was completely unnecessary.
I'm disappointed that Silver Elite is even in there because Silver Elite did absolutely nothing.
The world doesn't make sense. The magic doesn't make sense. The politics of humans living in a world with magic users and their own politics is never explained.



