I gave it two stars. I didn't hate it on the same level as People We Meet on Vacation and Happy Place. It didn't make me rage.
Plant Based Bride 238K subscribers Β· Nov 8, 2025
Why No One Can Agree on Emily Henry ππ ranking, reviews, & analysis
- Ranking Β· 6 books
And I gave this one four stars. Probably if I did do half stars, it would probably be around a three and a half, but round it up. And I really liked this one, mostly for the characters.
And I really loved their dynamic. The way they fell for each other felt very natural. It was very sweet.
I really, really, really, really loved it. My favorite of any Emily Henry I've read. Made me cry a lot.
I gave this book one star. There are so many things to dislike about this book. I was going to say the main issue is, but really it's everything.
I didn't like this book. I did not have fun with it. The whole time I just felt like I'm being told that these are the best friends of all time.





