Outlaw Bookseller 21.6K subscribers · Nov 2, 2023

If You Like 'Children of Time', You'll Love 'The Seedling Stars': James Blish & Pantropy #sf

Reviews3

Loved

now of course when you talk about James BL the thing that everybody talks about and it's fair enough cuz it's a great book it's an interesting book is of course a case of conscience this is my original Arrow copy which I bought new way back in the early 80s still very beautiful and pristine and it's a book which lingers in your mind and it does make you think

Loved

there is something which is equally interesting and to my way of thinking probably more interesting but what I'm saying is do read these but once you've SE them out or even before try and find this book The neglected Masterpiece the seedling Stars the ultimate story of pantropy total genetic engineering the 1950s equivalent of today's children of time by Adrien shikovski and because it's earlier because it's pioneering there is an argument that it is better either way you must read it

Disliked

and also more recently a pantropy book which I really dislike because it did virtually nothing with the concept was Becky Chambers book to be taught if fortunate which I love the title of I love the cover of I wanted to like it sorry Becky but it was just so light on ideas and too much on the touchy feely stuff which she seems to think passes SF and I know a lot of you like her but we have to differ on this