Mike's Book Reviews 151K subscribers · Nov 8, 2024

Weekly Update: August 10th, 2024 | The One Where I React To Your Hot Takes on the Grimdark Subgenre

Reviews3

Mixed

I think the biggest problem with this one and with the Talisman was that it takes a long time to say anything and once it finally gets that point where what you've been waiting for is happening it kind of ends. so it's another one of those where I feel like this story could have really been paired down a little bit in the editing room

Mixed

with this I love the aliens I think the way that they're how unique and fresh and original the aliens are feeling in this is very cool I think that the actual science is very interesting. now that they're off of the what they started the planet called angan so after they're off of that planet and they're on to the next place I feel like it's gotten better but for me it's like the characters are so flat

Mixed

I said I was very mixed on Talisman I liked a lot of things about it I love the territories I loved the coming of age with Jack I liked like the friendship with another character it's one of those things where it was just other parts of it that really kind of L me down