this is definitely my favorite of all the books I have read from the long list and this is just a sort of book that I was going to love anyway
Reviewing (some) of the Booker Prize Longlist
I didn't initially love it enough that it managed to make me feel like I had to carry on reading but there's also nothing about it that I like didn't like
I don't know just like boot one of those books off and add a book like burn and wood that's doing something completely different to any of the other books so yeah don't really get it because I think it's an amazing book
the only other book I read by this author is Without End which I didn't enjoy at all but I really don't like Western
I think the first short story was really strong really smart and Darkly funny and cutting and then I think the others sort of in between were fairly forgettable
I think this book is pretentious and boring
this book is a super interesting one I think it would be a great book club read the only other thing I want to say about this book is that Sebastian Barry can write some of his descriptions are absolutely beautiful
it went from feeling like a five-star book to a two star book at point so I feel super conflicted about this one
do I think this book could have been shaved by at least 50 pages yes certainly do I think it would have been a stronger book if it had have been yes but will I still follow this author's career definitely I'll definitely pick up what she brings out next so my feelings are sort of mixed about this one
within those first 35 Pages it felt like we were being told a lot and not shown it felt very subtle very gentle and very soft and very distanced I felt at a real remove from these characters









