MercysBookishMusings 40.4K subscribers · Mar 8, 2020

Women's Prize 2020 Longlist | Chat

Reviews12

Disliked

then i read bel canto and had big issues with it too long there's a really uncomfortable relationship in terms of age and power which was never commented on which i have big issues with

Loved

so girl woman is just phenomenal and i find it crazy if you would read this book and not think it's brilliant so i haven't heard anyone say that yeah i'm sure there is someone who thinks that if so why it's brilliant i really love it and i'm so glad it is there

Loved

i was 100 sure it would be there you know i really wanted the unseen world which is her previous novel that came a few years ago to make it to the long list but i could sort of understand why that one didn't it's a particular type of novel it's very slow but long break river i think is like the exact type of book that they have on their long list but it's not there and yeah i'm so shocked

Mixed

i think it was trying to do some interesting things but with not enough depth and i think for readers who drop in and out of reading more like who don't read loads and who get their recommendations from prize lists this is a great book for people like that to read because it does discuss issues which lots of you know run-of-the-mill books which publishers push out don't discuss it has a really good commentary on racism particularly as it pertains to also being you know like being a black woman in the intersection of those things but there's plenty of books that do it with much more nuance and depth so yeah it just wasn't for me

Loved

i also thought the bass rock by evie wilde should have been on there but i also thought maybe it wouldn't make it i would like even though i don't like the booker i'd still like to see on the booker list because i feel like she deserves you know some more like marketing and acclaim and stuff

Disliked

then i read the magician's assistant i think it's assistant i also felt there was some issues with that one in terms of the power balance of their relationship which again was never discussed or commented on and i also didn't like there were some sort of dream like sequences which really turned me off so i didn't like that

Loved

i really wanted the unseen world which is her previous novel that came a few years ago to make it to the long list but i could sort of understand why that one didn't it's a particular type of novel it's very slow

Disliked

it's a very short book so i could have just forced myself to finish it but i thought [ __ ] it why should i don't like it so this is a very particular thing i think loads of people could love this it is literally just not the writing style for me

Mixed

my biggest issue with it is everyone had the same [ __ ] name then and it's so hard to follow and it's not even like you can be pissed off of hillary mantell because these are real people so she's not chosen to call everyone like [ __ ] thomas or william they just are all called that so that's really hard to get on board with and also my knowledge of the tudor era is like [ __ ] next to zero