MercysBookishMusings 40.4K subscribers · Jan 28, 2023

Five Star Predictions | Wrap Up

Reviews9

Liked

I love this book this book is super queer and there's lots of really open and Frank discussions between the characters there's loads of really just cool interesting people and yeah I really enjoyed this and we'll definitely pick up what the author brings out in the future

Disliked

the writing style is too dripping in like romance and sweetness and I was gutted when I dnf this one because I had been so excited for a couple of years about reading it and was convinced I would love it but yeah didn't like the writing style

Loved

the earlier essays which are much more focused on her sort of coming of age her relationship with her parents are just beautiful like this is what I think is like beautiful lyrical language done right the descriptions just took my breath away

Disliked

I found the writing style was just sort of it served its purpose it told the story it did no more than that and I also felt at a few points even when she was writing about her life as a child there was a few points where I felt that she was a bit unkind about people and judgmental

Disliked

I didn't like the writing style at all but more than that I didn't like the way in which the themes and the characters were handled this felt very cliche very tropey very exaggerated to me and this didn't feel like a subtle or nuanced description of these people and the lives they might lead

Mixed

I thought there were section of this which were just so poetic and so beautiful and I think the way in which she describes members of her family is breathtaking and she can really capture a person and a place I think maybe this was just a bit too long and maybe it needed to be edited down a little bit