MercysBookishMusings 40.4K subscribers · Aug 3, 2024

Reacting to the Booker Prize Longlist 2024

Reviews12

Disliked

I thought she was very kind of tropy and flat manic pixie dream girl type character and I also thought the book was a bit messy and also kind of uninteresting a lot of points so that was a real disappointment for me

Disliked

it reminded me a little bit although I did much prefer the writing style in this one but it also dnf it of like the great circle by Maggie shipstead that kind of Great American novel kind of zoomed out focus and yeah I just don't like that at all

Disliked

then yeah also this kind of weird narrative device was being used that I really didn't like and I just felt like this would have been strong as like a single short story one and done and I wasn't interested in carrying on and I also didn't feel at all connected to the characters

Mixed

I kind of really enjoyed all that I thought the dialogue was great but the book you plot-wise I thought it got really messy and I thought she just lost her grip on it towards the end so it ended up being a kind of midre for me

Disliked

I thought that it was a book that was badging itself as deeply feminist and actually felt the opposite to me in terms of its portrayal of women I found it yeah just kind of frustrating unbelievable there was some repeated metaphors and repeated imagery that I found annoying

Disliked

I found that the overstory had that voice that's kind of distinctly like big American Author voice where I am entirely aware that I'm being told a story and I feel really held at a kind of remove from a said story

Mixed

ultimately I think I ended up giving that book three stars but I really love the writing style I thought the writing style was really excellent and I just thought that some of the plot points weren't executed excellently