MercysBookishMusings 40.4K subscribers · Jun 14, 2024

Reviewing My 5 Star Predictions (with mixed results)

Reviews8

Loved

what I'll say is I loved this book and if you like this sound of I'd highly recommend it and I'll definitely reread it and I'll definitely read whatever this author brings out. so this is so far one of my favorite reads of the year

Disliked

this was a really mixed bag there was moments of really beautiful writing clearly the research had been done and I was left feeling that this could have been a really great novel if maybe more time been spent on it or it had been better edited. so yeah I don't think I'd pick up another book from this author because it just ended up feeling a bit kind of messy and clunky

Mixed

I managed to read about a third of this around 100 Pages before deciding to give up on this and I will say like this is entirely a me thing rather than a book thing based on the 100 pages I read so far. I was just reading this thinking the writing's good but I'm just not really connected and I'm not really interested in reading about this kind of historical World in this tone anymore.

Loved

I read I have some questions for you by Rebecca McKai last year really loved that would have been a festar read for me if it wasn't just for some kind of tiny little bits of clunky writing that made me cringe a tiny bit and maybe the ending being just a little bit frustrating

Liked

this book is really nuanced like the book really examines all the flaws but yet the reasons for the flaws of all the characters. so yeah I ended up really enjoying this like I said and I definitely recommend it ended up being like a three and a half star read for me

Loved

I was wrong I absolutely love this book and like I said did give it five stars one of the best books I've read so far this year. it is just a beautiful look at this community and even though lots of sad things happen I felt so much joy reading this and I yeah I loved it

Liked

I found this book entirely readable like it was very easy to read very easy to turn the pages I found that I liked all the themes this book was exploring. I think instead this novel explores this friendship group explores a life really tenderly and quite carefully and yeah I think it was really interesting and I liked her writing style