MercysBookishMusings 40.4K subscribers · Jul 11, 2023

Ranking 2023 Anticipated Releases | Part 1

Reviews15

Disliked

I think premise-wise, theme-wise, I found this book really interesting. I like that idea of like somebody going missing or there being some crime element that hasn't really been uncovered and then in the present day somebody looking into that. But I just don't think the writing style was that great.

Loved

And then lastly, my favorite book, and I think this is probably my favorite read of the year so far, is Birnam Wood by Eleanor Catton. I again said I would review this and still haven't. I still hope to.

Disliked

Like moments like that where I think she really captured what it is to be a young girl, especially in a group of young girls, that I really enjoyed. But I felt there was too many things that I felt held at a distance from.

Liked

Initially, I really enjoyed this book. I think there's elements of her writing style which that are really nice and I will definitely pick up what she writes in the future. But I felt that, especially towards the end of this book, again, this is quite a short book, it's only a couple of hundred pages, the author wraps this all up in too neat a bow.

Liked

And this is the last of Tayari Jones' books I had to read because I'm a really big fan of her work and I really enjoyed this one. It isn't, you know, my favorite of her books, but I still think it's worth reading if you enjoy her work.

Mixed

On the one hand, this book could be looked at as like this massive achievement. And on the other hand, you could say this book is like a slight failure. And I'm still not quite sure where I sit on that.

Liked

I enjoyed this book. I think it was too short for what it was attempting to do. I think it was attempting to fit in quite a large history, and you know, quite a big shift in this character's life.

Disliked

I thought the writing was like really basic and just like easy to read, but there was absolutely nothing special about it. I thought it ticked a lot of key points that we're used to seeing in gothic historical fiction. I just didn't feel like it was offering me anything new at all, and it wasn't doing any anything in like a particularly special way.