MercysBookishMusings 40.4K subscribers · Apr 6, 2022

Reading Wrap Up | March 2022

Reviews10

Loved

However, I think that individually, all of these speeches are excellent. I really love what she has to say and how she says it, and I also think that I didn't really mind reading things that felt like a repeat, because I felt like it, like, embedded it in my mind, and like repetition made me remember it more, which I quite enjoyed.

Disliked

And so what you have is a dual timeline narrative that's been done to death, with nothing particularly new or special about it, which feels really cruel, like the writing isn't bad by any means, but like, yeah, none of it feels particularly new or exciting. So like for me, this is a two star read.

Disliked

The second half becomes much more focused on one suspect they have in particular and actually, you finish the book and feel like Tina Fontaine's been entirely lost, and it's become what i don't want true crime to be, which is instead this big discussion, and like, character analysis of the person who may or may not have done it, and I just don't think that's the, the whole point in Tina Fonstein's story being so big, was because it was representative of a massive issue in Canadian culture, and just focusing on this one individual who may have done it, isn't really addressing that. So in the end I just found this book entirely frustrating and I wouldn't recommend it, rant over.

Mixed

And I admired the world building and like I said, it was all quite complex and I found that all quite intriguing. And I also think the writing style I enjoy, closer to Robin Hobb, in that it feels quite sort of old-worldy, I guess. However, what I think this really lacked for me, was character development.

Liked

I think maybe, this book for me, like the wrap up of it, wasn't as strong as the sum of its parts, but I still definitely recommend it and it felt quite unusual, and like I said, it does comment on the trouble.

Loved

I absolutely love this. I gave it five stars and it's the sort of book I find really difficult to talk about, and like how to convince you to pick it up because this type of non-fiction book, the only way in which I can like convince you to read it, I sometimes feel is just by like repeating everything I was told in the book, and being like, and then I learned this, like this is really fascinating, and this was really insightful.