Life on Books 102K subscribers · Feb 8, 2026

Saying goodbye to books...

Reviews14

Mixed

But I thought it was okay. some of it I really enjoyed. Other parts it was like, "Okay, let's just get on with it here." It was a little bit unnecessarily wordy and the prose themselves didn't really do it for me.

Disliked

There was something about this book that was so triggering to my ADHD, I just could not concentrate while I was reading this. It was like the words were going in one eyeball and out the other.

Liked

I would put this book in the good but not great category. it's a very long book but extremely readable. I found myself really engrossed with the story but there were just a few things regarding the historical accuracy that kind of put me off and I think kept it from reaching that great status.

Disliked

And there are some interesting characters in this book, but what I ultimately really did not like about it was its extremely scattered narrative. In fact, I usually like it. But in this book, I just did not think it was well executed and there were some potentially very interesting storylines that kind of just didn't go anywhere.

Liked

They're more just thrillers, but some of the stories in this book I thought were great and I thought would make excellent full-length novels or maybe even great adaptations as films. But again, I just don't see myself going back to this book.

Liked

I actually enjoyed Frankenstein, but I somehow ended up with three copies of this book, so I don't want to keep this one with the Netflix sticker on it, even though it would look good on my Penguin Classics shelf with the white stripe.

Disliked

And again, there's some good setups here, but then it kind of just doesn't really go anywhere. The writing just feels a little passive and it's just a bit humdrum overall.

Liked

Easily one of the funniest books I've ever read, but it's extremely lowbrow, which is not really my thing, particularly when it's not lowbrow used to kind of tell a more highbrow story or a story with highbrow themes. This is just basically straight-up comedy, which if that's your type of thing, that's great. I enjoyed reading it.

Disliked

And then in part two of the book it shifts into a completely different style of writing, storytelling. You could maybe call it magical realism and I did not enjoy it. And part two is very lengthy and when you get back to the kind of normal narrative in part three at that point I just felt so detached from the book.

Disliked

And yeah, very unlike the other Denis Johnson works I've read, I didn't really think it was that good. it was kind of entertaining, probably would make a great movie, but I was chatting with someone in our book club, Phil, who's a big Denis Johnson fan, and he was saying that Johnson basically wrote this because he wanted to make some money to put a pool in at his house or something like that, which I think it kind of shows in the writing, so definitely don't need to keep this one on my shelf.

Liked

It's a very moving story in that way, but I as a man who will never be pregnant and doesn't have kids just didn't really connect with it that much, but it's got beautiful prose. It's got the kind of typical understated Japanese storytelling with short sentences, but it really works for the story here. Definitely a book I would recommend for the right reader, but I don't see myself rereading it.