Life on Books 102K subscribers · Dec 8, 2025

I thought this was the great American novel, until...

Reviews6

Disliked

And I also felt like Russell Banks wanted to write a very slow burn book, but just took it a little bit too far. And you felt like the cork never really popped on the pressure that was building in the story.

Mixed

But I thought that for as creative as Mary Shelley was and how incredible the pros were for somebody who wrote this as a teenager, which is just insane, I did think that the overall storytelling was a little bit weak and it just it just meandered.

Loved

And this little book packs a huge punch. Again, you could read it in a single sitting if you really wanted to. It's very approachable as far as the language used, but it is got a it's just a hard read because it's an emotionally devastating book.