Library of a Viking 79.7K subscribers · Nov 8, 2024

Asking Famous Authors Their Favourite Book, Then Reading It

Reviews10

Loved

When I read this, I was absolutely utterly obsessed with it. So, what I will say about the Green Bone Saga is that this is the definition of a fresh take on fantasy. It's like a Godfather-esque kind of story, but set in an urban, modern, Asian-inspired setting.

Loved

Jade Legacy literally spans over 10 years time and we get to see this massive complicated family drama and clan wars evolve over a very long period of time and it is just absolutely masterfully done.

Liked

Now, I feel like everyone that watches my channel, they will know that I actually read the first trilogy, and I really loved it, but I actually think the first book in this trilogy is definitely the weakest one. Now, it's not very written, as I said, I did enjoy it, but it's kind of like a Hunger Games in space kind of setting.

Disliked

It's a super popular modern fantasy book with lots of humor, lots of absurdism, and some really interesting world building. But this novel is a novel I read and I didn't really love it. I know people often get annoyed with me when I say that I don't really connect with novels that have like loads of swashbuckling, loads of humor.

Disliked

Secondly, I found the story to be crazy hard to follow. I genuinely went online to check if I was reading book three or four in the series. I feel like Jack Vance, he barely explains anything that happens.

Loved

Now, full disclosure, I have actually read The Way of Kings and it is honestly one of my all-time favorite fantasy books, but it's also one of those fantasy novels I feel every modern fantasy reader has read, but it is a solid introduction. If you're looking for massive epic world building, fantastic characters, and really accessible writing style, then Brandon Sanderson is your guy.

Disliked

Yes, the story overall was interesting. Basically following this young girl that experienced that her father is absolutely brutally murdered, and then she goes on a revenge, and she wants to hunt down the person that murdered her father, and she gathers this band, and I think overall the plot and the tone and the atmosphere is really well done. But there's just something about Charles Portis' writing that I just I struggled to connect with it.