I loved this. I loved it. I have nothing negative to say about this book.
everything i read this fall ๐๐น (so far)
But for me, the ending just muddled the narrative entirely and stripped away basically all of the meaning that the story had for me up to that point.
Unlike Lucas, my other most recent Ali Hazelwood man who was predominantly tall and Swedish as his main personality traits. Eli is tall, but he's also hardworking and self-sacrificing sometimes to a fault.
It's because I really liked the first two books and I was thrilled to see where the series would go, but I knew that I wanted to have a lot of time and a lot of like free mental load to be able to enjoy it as much as I possibly could.
But the ending sequence of this book is fantastic. It was so good.
But the further that I got with this, and it didn't take very long for my feelings to change, the further I got, the more that optimism was just sapped out of me because this book is just so [ __ ] boring.
I just think it tried to do too much. It had too many characters. It had too many relationships to really flesh out any single one of them.
I gave this three stars, and it's a mixed three star. This isn't like an average forgettable three star. I had pretty strong positive and negative opinions when I was reading this.
I mean, obviously, I thought The Notes was better. It was one of the only books I gave five stars last year.
I really enjoyed the way that this book was structured. I feel like it did multiple timelines super well because you're also while everything is happening at the summer camp, you're going back in time through flashbacks to the previous investigation for the previous missing kid.
I thought that overall this was really good. I gave it four stars. I would say that this has this Atlantic article kind of vibe to it.
I gave this book two stars almost entirely because of the writing. I actually thought that the story overall had some really poignant character moments and a really interesting foundation for a world and for a magic system that the way I described it earlier makes it sound really derivative.











