I think at this point in the series, I started feeling a little mix of like I love certain silly overdramatic parts to this book, but other parts of that, like other silly and overdramatic parts, started to just like take me out of the immersion of everything and started feeling a little bit too just like I couldn't suspend my disbelief that far.
I read 18 books in September... let's talk about it | READING WRAP UP πβοΈ
I don't know about you guys, but this one didn't feel as strong to me. I've been complimenting Demi Winters for not spoonfeeding things to us through the entire series. But for some reason, it started feeling she was spoon feeding things to us in this book.
And unfortunately, I just didn't love this one as much. Like it started going like down and down and down and down a little bit for me.
I think all of her character perspectives in this book in particular were so strong. She's introduced all of these characters that have different traumas that have different very specific struggles and the way they overcome these traumas are very different journeys
But even so, reading them from such a intimate perspective from Chanel's personal experience was so impactful because she wrote it in such a strong way. Like you can tell she's a strong writer.
I love Bonnie Garmas. I loved Lessons in Chemistry, so I was looking forward to reading this.
So there were a few moments that felt a little bit silly like that for me, but overall very interesting story, very great historical fiction.
I think I liked this book, but I honestly don't know if I loved it and I was a little bit disappointed in that because I was expecting to absolutely love this book because I know it's so beloved by so many readers.
This one was kind of a letdown for me. It was okay. I love Bonnie Garmas. I loved Lessons in Chemistry, so I was looking forward to reading this.
Now, I honestly found it a little bit tough to vibe with the writing style in this book. It felt very detached, and I don't think it really enticed me to like get to know the characters on a deeper, more intimate level. And because of that, I never really felt connected to the characters.
I enjoyed this nolla. It was super fun. We got some deeper insights into characters that were previously side characters and who are now taking a larger role in the series.
So yeah all that to say really enjoyed this one. It definitely felt a little bit more like a memoir than a fiction, honestly. Like, it felt very memoir in terms of how it read.
And I found the first book to be fun to read. Like, everyone was getting into trouble, students, teachers, staff. It was just highly entertaining to read.
My one critique about this one was that a lot of it felt very same sy samey to the first book in the duogy in terms of the journey that we followed like the specific order and plot structure of it. And while I get that there was a point to that, that really did fit on that theme of like rewriting history and like changing the tone of it and everything, I do think like for enjoyment purposes in terms of being a reader, I just wanted a little bit more variety, like just more that felt different to the first book. But yeah, all that to say, still so good.
I think Rachel Gillick writing is also just like so delicious and gothic and atmospheric. Perfect fall reads.
And I don't know, it just felt so fun and feel good. And it was definitely a book I needed at the time, like something to just really cheer me up and bring me out of the depths of some of like the more serious books that I sometimes read.
Now, this one is a romance that didn't work for me, so I don't want to spend too much time just like bashing this one down. It was just like it was just fine. It was just like not special for me.
All in all, I think the first book in this series was definitely stronger. If there's a next book in the series, I honestly don't think I would pick it up at this point after this one.
And with the second book, I did rate it a 4.5. I just feel like this one gave me almost everything I would ever want for a genre like this.
I do think yeah, the world building and everything was the strongest point in this book and that's what like made this book enjoyable for me to read. Obviously got emotional reading this book by the end of it.



















