Jack Edwards 1.7M subscribers · Feb 28, 2026

the WORST books i read in 2025 (of the 137 i read)

  • Biggest Disappointments of 2025 · 10 books

Reviews14

Beach ReadEmily Henry
Loved it

I am saying this as someone who has read all of her books, who read Beachread for the first time in 2025 and gave it five stars, would have given it six if I could.

EurotrashUnknown
Not a fan

This book though is about a tumultuous mother son relationship, and to me, I just found it a bit irritating. And it's only 190 pages, but it felt like a slog.

M trainPatti Smith
Not a fan

In M Train especially, she does my least favorite thing which is just recounting a bunch of dreams she had. It felt so mundane to me. It felt so self-indulgent perhaps. I feel like this book is so dull.

Pineapple StreetJenny Jackson
Not a fan

I would describe this book as being sort of like an episode of The Real Housewives, except nothing happens. There is no discernable story line and they all just become kind of like super woke at the end, but without any real substance, you know?

This feels like a book for the brain rot generation with no attention span who need to be told exactly what is going on and exactly how everyone feels in every single line. It is like the author thinks you're stupid. Everything feels so obvious.

Silver EliteDani Francis
Not a fan

This is the smuttification of dystopia. It's like 50 shades of 1984. This was about as revolutionary as a labu. It's lazy writing.