Jack Edwards 1.7M subscribers · Sep 28, 2023

i read every book Margot Robbie and Cillian Murphy have recommended (the real Barbenheimer battle)

Reviews13

Disliked

The characters are one-dimensional, even the plot isn't good because it's spoiled at every section by this princess who's having these kind of premonitions, I guess, about what will happen.

Mixed

I think it's a fun book and I definitely think it needs to be understood in the context of the time that it was written, where the character is the heroin based purely on the fact that she kind of flips gender expectations. But I think that it's feminism that we've kind of moved on from, if that makes sense.

Mixed

I thought this was heartfelt and impactful and a bold writing style that is anything but shy. But for me, I found that its fragmentation wasn't as effective as it could have been and overall I didn't feel massively connected to this character.

Liked

And it is beautifully written, very, very powerful, but it is not without its flaws. I think that the trouble with this book is that it does perpetuate a kind of white savior image because we essentially follow a white family who are given way more depth than any of the black characters.