But yeah, there was like five full chapters that was, you know, in the past and we were getting all of that context and stuff and I wasn't like loving that per se, but I did end up liking the direction of it and how it tied into part one, but it just wasn't really my favourite, but I probably would still give this like three star.
Gavin Reads It All 134K subscribers · Jun 8, 2026
Don’t Hate Me But I Read Sherlock Holmes And… 🔍🕵🏻♂️
I will be giving this one four stars or maybe 4.5. I'm not 100% sure. It's not one of my like five star Gothic novels, but it has that atmosphere.
So, I have finished The Sign of Four and I didn't really like this one. I'm not going to lie. I'm probably going to give like two stars.
I would probably give this one a 2.5. It could have been so close to being a 3.5 or a four, but it just plummeted in that second part. And I yeah, I ended up not really liking this all that much.



