I gave it like 4.5 stars. That book had so much mystique around the bunnies around the characters and this one just like obliterated it in 50 pages.
The Worst Books I Read in 2025 π«π
- Biggest Disappointments of 2025 Β· 15 books Β· counted in creators' Biggest Disappointments of 2025
And they were making this like whole issue of sex not being satisfying for them because it's too vanilla. And yet, they went on to have three vanilla sex scenes.
The role of women in that book. Awful. The way that they were so subservient and their portrayals were just genuinely vile to me.
It was the fastest love and romance with the slowest narration, the slowest storytelling style, and it was the most jarring thing that I've read all year.
This one was so incredibly painful to get through. I ended up DNFing at 103 pages so I do think I got quite a ways into this where I feel like I got a really good sense of where it was going and things were moving a little bit too quickly.
That one had a little bit of a weird hyperfixation on teenagers having sex and it was just making me feel uncomfortable. I didn't want to read it.
I read Part of Your World. That was also pretty disappointing, but it's not in my worst books.
Way too many conveniences with the main character as well. Way too much plot armour. Way too many things that don't make sense.
But then I did get into say you'll remember me and oh I did get 151 pages into this one so I did make it quite far but the characters were just like awful. Xavier the main love interest was awful.
It would just be a lot of traveling and battle traveling battle traveling battle the same things were happening over and over again. The same jokes were being told over and over again. I didn't like it.
So yeah, story was highly entertaining but so god awfully terribly written.
But because you wanted to pad this out so much, so aimlessly without any kind of direction, some of it felt like a waste of my time.
There was quite a lot of fatphobic undertones, some racist undertones as well. The main story line of like the whole Magic Toyshop thing, criminally underutilized.
I didn't give this one a one. I think I gave this one like maybe a two star, maybe 1.5 star. That .5, that 1.5 will have been only for this character and this one set piece in this book that I really thoroughly enjoyed.
It was getting rid of all of the mystery surrounding them and a lot of the allure there as well with the characters just fizzled out so quickly.
The witchcraft part of this so underutilised. It's not even creatively integrated in the story as well.















