gabbyreads 108K subscribers Β· Sep 8, 2026

reviewing the 31 books I've read this summer πŸ“šβ˜•οΈπŸ“– [July and August Wrap Up]

Reviews41

Disliked

It was the way that the man was written in this book, he was like immediately kind of like giving me the ick. And once I started to get a grasp on like what the story was actually about, I was like, "Yeah, I don't know if I care about this."

Loved

This was so entertaining and I feel like this also had a lot of commentary on so many different things. This book even had a little bit of a plot twist that I did not see coming that I was so shocked by. Chuck Tingle just really outdid himself with this book and I loved it so much.

Liked

I also loved that both Greta and Valdin were queer characters and kind of like reading about their experiences in the dating world was really entertaining. There was just something like so humorous about the writing style in this that really worked for me.

Mixed

And honestly like towards the end of the book as we were getting to like the later times like 2015 and then 2020, it just really lost all of that magical nostalgia that the beginning of this book had for me and all of the political commentary in this book from like 2015 onward. Even though I definitely agreed with everything that it was saying and everything that it was being critical of, it just felt a little bit too heavy-handed.

Loved

The fact that I found a slasher that I would probably like reread this book in the future. Like that is crazy to me cuz I don't usually get invested in slashers like this. So this one was such a fun time.

Disliked

But it all just felt a little bit too heavy and bleak and depressing for me personally. Like this is just not the tone that I wanted from this book because I swear once you reach like the halfway point almost all the way through the end, it is just non-stop depressing.

Mixed

Plot in this book was so addicting. And it was part of the reason why I enjoyed this book so much because I could never guess where the story was going. But then I feel like what really dragged this book down for me is that the quality of the writing in my opinion, it just wasn't very good.

Mixed

I did love the general vibes of this book. Like the creepy kind of like island setting was really fun. And the way that they were filming this movie I thought was really interesting, but my god, the writing in this book got so repetitive

Disliked

Something that nobody told me when I started this book is that this one is technically it's actually a sequel to Wonderland, which is one of my least favorite Jennifer Hillier books. Like that's one of her only books that I rated really low.