gabbyreads 108K subscribers Β· Jun 8, 2026

I read 19 books in May πŸ“šβ˜•οΈπŸͺπŸ“– (so many new favorites) MAY WRAP UP

Reviews24

Disliked

Some of it was like really fun and really creepy, but a lot of it just kind of felt like cheesy to me, because like there would be scenes where she's actually like talking and like having dialogue with the monsters, and they're like negotiating. Also just read kind of clunky to me, because each one of the chapters, I guess it was like originally a bunch of different short stories on Reddit, and then they ended up putting them all together for this book, and I feel like you can kind of tell.

Disliked

And so, I loved hearing about their jobs specifically. Like, I really loved their passion for weather. That was definitely like my favorite thing about this book. But then, the romance in this book just really, really, really didn't work for me.

Liked

The only reason why I didn't give this one five stars is because this book is a little bit long and at times it was starting to feel repetitive in the second half. And I also at times I found AJ to be like a little bit annoying because she has like a lot of insecurities that keep getting brought up like over and over again. But otherwise, this was kind of like a perfect book for me and I just absolutely adore these characters.

Disliked

I don't know, I find all of the characters to be pretty obnoxious and I feel like this book has only been frustrating for me to read so far because it's just introducing so many characters and different timelines and I'm already getting confused.

Disliked

One of the books that I DNF that I already talked about in a reading vlog is Our Perfect Storm by Carley Fortune. I've realized about myself that I really don't like childhood friends to lovers as a trope in romance unless it's gay.

Disliked

And like, maybe I should have gone into this with lower expectations because this one is actually a collection of short stories, which includes the book Rest Stop, which is a novella that I read a while ago, and I think I gave Rest Stop two stars when I read it.

Mixed

I was actually so invested in this book in the beginning but then as we got closer to the second half and you start to realize like what's actually happening, I just quickly started to lose interest and like I was saying a lot of the commentary just felt so heavy-handed that I was like, "Oh my gosh, like I get it."

Liked

This book was just so creepy and so entertaining. Something that I absolutely loved about this story was actually Macy's character and her relationship that she had with her younger sister. I think the only reason why I didn't end up giving this one a higher rating is because some of the plot ended up getting a little bit repetitive.

Loved

And I actually would recommend if you read this book and you're looking for something similar that could actually make you cry, I would recommend The Story Life of A.J. Fikry because that is one of my favorite books of all time and I did see a lot of similarities with this book and that book.

Mixed

It's a really, really beautiful and touching premise, and I do think that this is a book that I probably would have loved if I had read it a few years ago. I just feel like my reading taste has changed a little bit over time, and I'm not really reaching for books like this anymore that are like really sappy, really like heartfelt stories that are like intended to make you cry. And not only that, but I just feel like I never really felt that connected to the characters and I can't really explain why.

Loved

So, I can't wait to see what this author does in the future, and I would highly, highly recommend Yesteryear. I think it's worth the hype, and it's definitely one of my top favorite books that I've read this year.