gabbyreads 108K subscribers Β· Nov 8, 2025

the best reading month I've had all year πŸ•·οΈπŸ•ΈοΈπŸŽƒπŸ‘» so many new favorite horror books [October Wrap Up]

Reviews19

Liked

I mean, I did read this one in the dark entirely, so I do think that might have contributed to like why I thought it was so creepy at times, but like in my opinion, this book had the perfect balance of like creepy and campy kind of horror. This one also takes place in like the early 2000s and like the late '9s, so I just thought the atmosphere in this was so good and it made me feel so nostalgic for that time.

Loved

It's just so entertaining and it's very twisty. Like there was a lot of things that I didn't see coming and it was just so fast-paced. Like there was not a dull moment in this book for me and I loved the atmosphere of like Joshua Tree and like being out in the desert in the middle of nowhere.

Loved

I just really loved the writing in this book. I thought the writing was so atmospheric and so brilliant. And I also loved the amount of queer characters that we had in this book and that was also something I wasn't really expecting.

Loved

Like, it just got so unhinged, but like in the best way possible. And I'm just so excited to learn that A24 is going to be adapting this into a movie with Zack Efron as the lead.

Disliked

I've seen so many people describe this book as being like very emotional and very touching and like I can definitely see why, but I just don't think the story really worked for me. I didn't really connect with any of the characters and like some of it just felt so cringey to me and so over the top and the way that they'd be like, "You listen to all of us, but who's listening to you?"

Liked

I do think some of their conversations like in the past chapters, they just felt a little bit like surface level or like kind of shallow to me. And so I definitely preferred the present- day chapters because I thought their chemistry and like the tension between them in the present day was just so well written.

Disliked

I also temporarily have DNFed People Watching, but I only got about like less than 50 pages into this one. I just wasn't really connecting with either of the characters right away, but I think I'm going to come back to this one at another time.

Disliked

And after 80 pages in like I am just really not vibing with the writing in this. I'm not liking either of the characters very much and I just don't know if this author is the romance author for me.

Liked

And I was just so locked into this audiobook the entire time I was listening and I kept being like, "What am I listening to right now? Like what is even happening right now?" But in the best way, like this book just continued to surprise me and shock me.