Freya Valerio 51.6K subscribers · Jan 8, 2026

Are the highest-rated books on Goodreads worth reading? *bookmas day 8*

Reviews27

Mixed

Personally, I probably would put this in the romanty category over fantasy because the love story, I wouldn't say it's a romance, but like the love story in this played a really, really big part.

Loved

Obviously, this is probably one of my top reads of the entire year. I know that so many of you agree this just was an emotional roller coaster of a book in the best way possible. I think it was everything I could want.

Liked

The other one I was kind of tempted to vote for was Rewind It Back by Liz Tom Ford, which I did not expect, but this is the last book in the Windy City series, and I actually thought the romance in this was so cute, guys.

Loved

You're voting for the story, the emotional journey our characters went on, the character arcs in this. Like, it was a crazy good book, but I wasn't there for the romance. In fact, the romance kind of annoyed me.

Loved

But the whole book of course has such an incredible emotional impact. I have been starting to dip my toes into historical fiction a little bit more and I think this was a really great place to start my Kristen Hannah journey.