Emmy Rosam 83K subscribers Β· Nov 8, 2025

The 19 books I read in October πŸ“šβœ¨ October reading wrap up

Reviews22

Liked

I don't think these type of dark fantasy stories are like my favorite to read, but I think that the story was crafted in a very thought-provoking way, and the commentary in this was very critically reflective of a lot of [snorts] things in life. So, I found those elements stuck with me when I was reading this story, but again, like, it is a very, very dark.

Liked

But because it is a lot more like fast-paced, plot-heavy in this short time constraint period, there's not too much like character depth and development in that, but I don't think it's supposed to be, you know? So, there were points where some of the characters annoyed me, but a lot of the time I felt like I was being gaslit, and I didn't know who to believe.

Liked

It was Some points are, you know, cringey and cheesy, but it's that fun like rom-com vibe, and I found the way that it was written to be listened to in audio really fun because it was quite engaging, and like, the concept of it was really fun where basically listening to two characters have a conversation over the phone.

Liked

So, I kind of read them backwards, but honestly, did not mind that, and I really enjoyed this, and everyone has since told me that they preferred book one to book two, and book one is even better, and a few people were quite disappointed with book two.

Loved

So, you can technically read this without having read Riftbound or Dustbound, but honestly, personally, for the best emotional impact, for the most understanding of the world, to really get the hype of this book and why everyone's kind of freaking out over it, I would definitely recommend reading those two books first.

Mixed

Book one, I really enjoyed. Book two and three, I was like, I'm loving where this story has gone and where we've ended up. But I'd seen people say, "Book two, okay, yeah. Book three, the two of them could have maybe just been one story and kind of giving middle book syndrome, feeling like a little bit of a filler." So book four, I was maybe expecting a little bit more, and it felt like the least amount of plot happened.

Loved

We definitely have more of a pirate seafaring siren vibe in this. It's very atmospheric, very misty. We're traveling to like different parts of the world, and we really did see an expansion with the characters and the world and the storyline in this.

Mixed

I think it was a interesting story, but it's not one that I'm going to like rave about or recommend loads. It is a cult classic, and I'm glad that I've read it, but not a favorite. So, I didn't I didn't dislike it. I just don't think it's for me.

Liked

If Not for My Baby by Kate Golden is a rockstar romance that I picked up, and I loved this book at the start, and then at some point during it, I was like, "I actually don't know how I feel about this." And then it picked up again, and I ended up loving it.

Loved

So, you can technically read this without having read Riftbound or Dustbound, but honestly, personally, for the best emotional impact, for the most understanding of the world, to really get the hype of this book and why everyone's kind of freaking out over it, I would definitely recommend reading those two books first.

Loved

But, this was my favorite read of this that they've put out, and I cannot wait to see what they continue to write. I think it was really fun. It's honestly one of the best books with trials in a fantasy setting that I've read in a long time.

Liked

I'm very intrigued to see where the story goes because the plot kind of got a little bit stagnant towards the middle and the end when we started focusing more on the characters and like developing individual relationships a little bit, but I had a really fun time reading this. This was very entertaining.