Elliot Brooks 168K subscribers · Nov 8, 2024

RANKING BRANDON SANDERSON BOOKS ~ Cosmere tier ranking with Secret Projects

  • Ranking · 20 books

Reviews20

Mixed

I do find the things in da Shard really interesting similarly to how I described Emperor's Soul where it feels like a crucial thing to read for the cosmere the greater cosmere it just doesn't have as much to it in the way that I have come to expect in love

Disliked

on reread I liked it less and the pacing was the primary reason I just feel like it the things that we focus on are astounding to me when there's so many other things that I feel like are really interesting and we kind of just either brush through those things or they're mentioned having occurred in a paragraph or they don't get a lot of time and then the things I don't care about as much get tons of time

Disliked

this Still Remains one of my least favorite things in the cosmere for one specific scene it's what I call the reunion scene and I hate it I hate it so much I think it's corny I think it goes so against the tone and the feeling of the hero of Ages and I can't stand it

Loved

I think that the reveals that you get in that are really masterfully done they're unexpected because there is this mystery in the second book and then you realize that the mystery is not contained to the second book which I thought was awesome

Liked

I just don't have that really strong connection to them I do like the setting I think it's so different from what we are accustomed to in fantasy but overall era 2 it's just kind of hard for it in general to break out of this middle tier

Liked

I really like her but it's just so short and it's hard to feel as strongly for her and her story and to really feel like I'm seeing the magic system at its fullest within such a short amount of time especially with how complex the magic is in this one but I still quite liked Emperor Soul

Loved

I love the getting to know Vin and keler and the mentor ment relationship I love just getting to know about alaman your first meeting seed you know there's all these great things about the final Empire that feeling of Hope and Rebellion

Liked

I liked the action scenes as well I thought some of them were kind of campy but in a really fun way and I thought they played into a lot of action tropes and once again in a fun way I think he did something really cool with them but the same character that kind of brings the series down overall had a moment that could have been really moving and instead it just became really ridiculous and that really took it down

Loved

well of Ascension by far my favorite one to reread I just love the politics of it I know it's not for everybody because if you don't like the politics then it's your least favorite likely but I love the politics of it I really like Vin her Arc in that second book and how she grows as a character and how she comes to terms with who she is