Elliot Brooks 168K subscribers · Nov 8, 2023

NEW FANTASY DNF'S

Reviews6

Disliked

the Yad era the writing style just felt very youthful and we would kind of shift from one thing to the next very quickly and it was already getting to be kind of repetitive so it was odd because it was like certain things were being repeated to me a lot but also so much would happen so quickly and with this almost like flippant air to it that it just didn't quite feel like adult fantasy

Liked

the first book is a goose girl retelling except for the main perspective is the villainous character from that story and so you're seeing why she does the things she does and the ways in which poverty has affected her ability to live the kind of desperation that comes with the lack of opportunities that you have when you are destitute those sorts of things so I really liked the first one

Disliked

the sun and the void as soon as it started there was just something about the writing where it's a very gripping opening as far as what's happening it's very heightened emotions very intense but I just didn't feel that intensity and I was Finding I wasn't really caring all that much about what was transpiring

Mixed

I thought the concept was cool I like the writing a lot I like the use of language that the author had has I would absolutely read something else by this author and I wasn't hating the book I didn't hate it at all and I found some of the little the Intrigue that mystery that was being built even though I didn't like the way that it was tied to first person I did I found myself curious about some of the things that were transpiring but I just didn't probably care enough to keep going

Mixed

I was so intrigued by the world I was so intrigued by the opening there's a lot of mystery it's really A very gripping start and I was really liking that but then the more it went the more it kind of slowed down and then we sort of took a backseat we would go to flashbacks it was a little disorienting and it felt like the longer I was reading the less interest I had