Elliot Brooks 168K subscribers · Nov 8, 2025

THE "TOP 50" FANTASY BOOKS OF THE LAST FIVE YEARS 🗓️ ranking best of fantasy books 📚 2021

  • Ranking · 15 books

Reviews13

Mixed

I liked aspects of this book, especially toward the beginning portion. I thought that the world was really fun and also just in general the setting itself was a lot different from what we typically see in fantasy and I appreciated that element of it. I was invested for a while and then at some point I wasn't really as much anymore and I have considered going back and rereading it.

Disliked

What I described about Malice is somewhat similar to this one where it didn't ultimately have that strong of an impact, but also I don't mind when stories at all are wearing their themes on their sleeves. I don't care if your themes are really subtle or if they're right in front of your face. But I think I find that if they're going to be right in front of my face, then I also want to have them not feel like you have to explain everything cuz it's like if they're really overt then maybe don't also explain them cuz like yeah, I got it cuz it's really obvious and a little bit I feel like the story was just kind of a little heavy-handed and it's a nolla so maybe if it had been a fulllength book and then we could have stretched it out a little bit and we didn't feel like we had to really make sure that we are clear about this theme, then I think maybe that would have worked for me.

Liked

Really enjoyed this one. I do think there is a certain point into the story all of a sudden we are going from we were primarily following one character and then all of a sudden we're following a bunch of other characters and you have to get caught up really fast.

Mixed

I thought that the thematic elements of Sorrowand were fantastic. It was really weird and also very creative and horror leaning in a lot of ways. And this one, my biggest thing is the tone discrepancies is how I'll refer to it as.

Mixed

I was very, very intrigued by this. I thought all of the various moving pieces on the board were having something engaging happening in their plots, but there are a couple of aspects to this that weren't quite working for me, which is why I sort of put it down because I had a feeling that if I completed it, I would feel the way I described feeling about the other ones in this tier.

Liked

I always felt like the characters took turns being the most interesting character, and I think that's really difficult to accomplish. So, I really enjoyed that aspect of it. I just don't know that I ever felt anything that hit me too much emotionally.

Liked

And the Wolf and the Woodsmen, it has a similar feeling in that you have this character who gets kind of like taken across the country and then they start out in this woodland area and then they end up even in this court environment and it's kind of folklore heavy and there's a lot of additional thematic elements that kind of seep into every little area they go to and there's this general almost horror feel to a lot of the environment. So, it has some, in my mind, some parallels to Uprooted. I just happen to have liked this one a little bit more.