Elliot Brooks 168K subscribers · Nov 8, 2025

LET’S TALK ABOUT THE GOODREADS CHOICE AWARDS NOMINEES 📚 fantasy, romantasy, ya fantasy

Reviews9

Mixed

Having since read it I think it's very historical fiction leaning with just a hint of speculative so I think I would have felt more comfortable with this being categorized as just fiction and allowed for maybe some other more fantasy leaning fantasy books

Loved

I hoped that ghost Smith by Nikki pal prto would show up it's not there that really bounds me out I don't know I consider that a snup I think that this duology deserve deserved excuse me some love and it's not there

Disliked

2020 was impressive it had rhythm of War Addy laroo and Empire of gold I was like those are Heavy Hitters and I think if I'm not mistaken I mean I can just check my notes I think even though these books didn't work for me that might have been the same yeah it was the same year that house and the Cilan sea came out

Disliked

2020 was impressive it had rhythm of War Addy laroo and Empire of gold I was like those are Heavy Hitters and I think if I'm not mistaken I mean I can just check my notes I think even though these books didn't work for me that might have been the same yeah it was the same year that house and the Cilan sea came out

Disliked

2020 was impressive it had rhythm of War Addy laroo and Empire of gold I was like those are Heavy Hitters and I think if I'm not mistaken I mean I can just check my notes I think even though these books didn't work for me that might have been the same yeah it was the same year that house and the Cilan sea came out