I still thought it was a lot of fun. Extremely heartwarming. I liked the characters.
Tier Ranking Every Fantasy Romance Book I Read From 2025 🫢
- Ranking · 20 books
I liked it. I thought it was it was pretty well written. I liked some of the thematic pieces of this.
I definitely liked the first book in this series the most. So, I think there is a level of just being kind of bummed out that the second and third books I didn't love as much as the first one, but I still overall quite like this.
And the dragons were kind of the only thing I liked about Fourth Wing.
So, the first book is campy. It is over the top and it is sometimes really dumb but playfully stupid.
I just thought it really embraced what it was in a way that I also found quite entertaining. So, I did very much enjoy that one.
I don't know that I was as in love with the plot and the love story necessarily as maybe I would be in my all-time favorites. , but I still thought it was fun and I enjoyed the kind of drama of it all and the starcross lovers feel to it.
I just had from start to finish a great time with this story. I enjoyed the characters. I enjoyed the stakes.
But I when I read it, I was like, "Oh, that was that was that was a fun time." It was a little different from a lot of the fantasy I've picked up because again, I would consider it more fantasy than fantasy romance.
It was still at the end of the day quite tropey though. But it was really, really fun.
Second half felt like tropier. this one, it was really just the beginning that I was kind of pulled in by and then everything else I was like, "Oh, this feels very familiar to a lot of what I've seen." So, it ultimately it just kind of it fell a little flat for me.
And there is something to be said of that style and the fun of it all. It is just not the style for me. And I felt like this story was kind of fitting within that.
It was still darling, but ultimately I wanted it to have a little bit more of some of the other emotions besides just like the a precious feeling. I wanted it to have a little bit of something else to pull me in and it didn't have that as much. It was very lush and beautiful and creative, but it was just a little too cotton candy cute for me.
And I thought thematically it was really great, but I wasn't invested in the love story basically at all. And that was a pretty central focus of how we were having this story all tied together.
This one would I always say it would pull me in and then I would get pulled out of it and then I'd get pulled in and I get pulled out of it and I just I felt like conceptually everything was quite cool and I liked the idea of the world and I liked the aesthetic you could say, but I think for me it kind of always sat in just being that.
I actually was quite invested in the first half, I would say, of this story. And then in the second half, I thought it actually started to get tropier.
I quite liked The Spell Shop by the same author.
I think this book did that really, really well. And I also thought quite often the characters behaved realistically. Even when it was frustrating, I was like, well, technically that is kind of a realistic response.
I enjoyed it. I didn't love it.
















