Elliot Brooks 168K subscribers Β· Jun 8, 2026

peak fantasy, fun sci-fi, commentary on publishing, and more πŸ“š reading wrap up

Reviews19

Loved

And this series is that perfect summer blockbuster, action-packed, so many twists and turns, so many oh my gosh, what's the one movie where they just like keep pulling off masks and it keeps being this like new reveal. It kind of had that feel to it.

Mixed

So, I liked the setup. I liked a lot of the little pieces that we were looking at and I did feel like the themes that were present. I do think that sometimes there's a you know, there's a debate as to how deep do you want to go when you're dissecting certain themes because sometimes you want there to be just enough where it adds a little bit of substance, it adds to the characters.

Mixed

So, I liked Dire Bound's world. I liked the way in which the motivations for the character were laid out. However, I did feel that even though it was fast-paced, even though it was action-packed and high-stakes and it was generally speaking a pretty fun time, I wasn't necessarily particularly invested and also I predicted everything that was going to happen in the story because it was so similar to a lot of the other works that have come out.

Liked

I liked the sort of fairy tale feel of that one, but it was the first time I felt a little bit worried about T. Kingfisher's works because she does write a lot and there have been a lot of conversations over the years about the level of editing, especially really well-known authors are getting because it's like once they become a household name, it can feel anyway to us as readers like maybe not as much is being putting into the editing and Hemlock and Silver just there's a little bit of repetition in ways that I thought like another round or two of edits would have cleaned up, not even two, just like one round of edits in addition to whatever else had been done. I feel like we would have really cleaned it up, tightened it, and it would have been probably among one of my favorites. I still liked it, but I didn't think it was as strong.

Liked

And then Snake Eater, I liked Snake Eater. It wasn't my favorite necessarily, but I was like, "Oh, I hope that magic that I have found present in T. Kingfisher's works, I hope that spark that I have with it doesn't get lost."

Liked

I will say that I still thought that certain character things were repeated too often and it ended up making it not feel quite as mature as maybe what it was going for. However, I still enjoyed this one and I do still plan to pick up the sequel.

Loved

And this series is that perfect summer blockbuster, action-packed, so many twists and turns, so many oh my gosh, what's the one movie where they just like keep pulling off masks and it keeps being this like new reveal. It kind of had that feel to it.

Loved

I really enjoyed it. I liked the main character a lot. I found the horror elements appropriately creepy, and also you think about some of them, and you're like, "Oh my gosh, that just sounds like I really feel like she wrote the ick factor."