Elliot Brooks 168K subscribers Β· Dec 8, 2025

Like these fantasy goodreads nominees? Here are some recommendations πŸ“š like this try that

Reviews18

Loved

I actually think Gideon the Ninth excels at utilizing the kind of humor that it does and sometimes trying to have something serious happen and almost having this escape room feel at times while also being really stupid simultaneously. And I think it blends it perfectly basically.

Liked

If you do like that fairy tale feeling and you like a little bit of humor, you like the friendship that develops, you like the sort of quest feeling that you get in things like Nettle and Bone, you might like this one as well.

Liked

But it does mean she is often overworked and underpaid and undervalued which is something that I think not only many people can relate to but I think what you see in Travis Baldry's works as well is how much you have to put in to make those seemingly little dreams become a reality.

Loved

One of the recommendations for this would be The Tainted Cup and a sequel, Drop of Corruption, as I do think both of these utilize the genre blending really, really well. And both of them have a mystery component and very specifically a murder mystery component while also having really deep lore and interesting worlds.

Mixed

Also, if you don't know, I recommend books even if they didn't work for me and The Book of Kohley wasn't perfectly to my taste, but I still think it's a good recommendation for if you like The Tainted Cup and a Drop of Corruption.