Because I did read the first book and then I didn't finish book two and I kind of just got rid of series because I felt like at that point so far it was basically like the TV show. I know that eventually it kind of diverged, but it just didn't feel worth it to read it when I had so many other books I wanted to read and just watch a TV show.
Are These Big Books Actually Worth the Time?
You can start with this one. I would probably recommend it more because I enjoy this one more, but I love the world building. In this one you get more about the magic kind of witchy-ish characters.
Because I did read the first book and then I didn't finish book two and I kind of just got rid of series because I felt like at that point so far it was basically like the TV show. I know that eventually it kind of diverged, but it just didn't feel worth it to read it when I had so many other books I wanted to read and just watch a TV show.
I've read Anna Karenina, and it does have similar chapters, but this time with hunting and horses, and I don't think they were necessarily worth it, but I don't think Russian classics were for me, to be fair.
With that said, I feel like the first like three, four hundred pages is the easiest five-star ever. It is unputdownable. Afterwards, this is where, you know, the pacing kind of goes up and down, which I don't think removing a few pages would be that bad.
So yeah, I have mixed feelings about this specific one. I didn't keep it because again, I hated that section so much. But I do think that the first 900 pages were worth it.
But, I did enjoy this one. It's a deeper exploration into these characters in a town in the countryside. So, it's an enjoyable one.
Either way, it's a long one, but I really enjoyed book one to the point where I would recommend it as a standalone. Obviously, you can continue, but I feel like book one was so much stronger. You do have to get into it.
The book just the content did not stick with me. I think the writing style was not for me. a lot of description kind of almost stream of consciousness.
And overall, I was really invested, but book three felt too short. Again, it sounds crazy, but the author did say that he realized the book was going to be too long, and he had to almost remove a section about one of the characters, and it was going to possibly be a companion series, which I hope he will because I did really enjoy the world, especially Caden.
I had read book one, and I had enjoyed it. Personally, I am a big fan of magical school, so you know, that's a great start. So, I was seeing some of the issues, you know, the cockiness of the male character, being him kind of judging his younger self, so I didn't really have an issue with this one except the romance.
This one, I think the critique, when it came out was supposed to be a stand-alone, so I feel like I didn't mind that there was a ton of world building, it made sense to me, but I feel like I was less equally divided interest-wise between the point of view, and it was too short. Which might sound crazy.
And I did enjoy the whole trilogy. It has like really classic tropes of like chosen one. The magic system is interesting.
The book was good, especially the beginning. The whole chapter where you see the disease spreading, the pandemic starting, fantastic. Afterwards, pacing was up and down for me.
I know the payoff is going to be worth it because again, world building magic system. He always has these crazy endings, these discoveries and that's what you get in book one and two.
But, book two >> >> was a mess in my opinion. The first 300 pages are like basically like book one. I had no problem, and it feels like the author realized that, "Oh I'm supposed to do all of these things, and I'm nowhere near that."
I did enjoy it. Honestly, I don't feel like the plot stuck with me as much as The Count of Monte Cristo. It was worth the what, 900 pages, but again, I am pretty used to reading French classics, so it didn't bother me.
So, it probably shouldn't be here, but for me it was definitely too long. I couldn't finish it because the pacing was all over the place. I feel like it was starting and starting and starting and starting and just not going anywhere.
Actually recorded my reaction of the ending of book two and I was losing my mind because again, it was great. So, so far, I feel like the series has been worth it, but I've heard mixed things about especially the book number five, the last one that came out.


















