BookswithEmilyFox 146K subscribers · Oct 25, 2026

Your Favorite Books Suck

Reviews24

Disliked

Which sounds harsh. for example, I wasn't as invested as much as I wanted to for All the Light We Cannot See or even The Book Thief, which I picked it up mostly because the narration is told from Death's point of view, which I thought that was brilliant, but then I read it and I felt nothing.

Disliked

But it was just so awful that I pushed through for book two because I was waiting for them to say, "No, that's not true. That's not what's happening." By the time I gave up, they still hadn't made it clear and I just could not get into it.

Disliked

At the end of book one, there is a twist that happens, which is seriously awful. Again, I can happily spoil it for you if you haven't heard it. But it was just so awful that I pushed through for book two because I was waiting for them to say, "No, that's not true.

Disliked

So book one and two were good, but book three was just really terrible. I thought the average rating would be lower. I mean it is lower than the other books, but not low enough >> >> in my opinion.

Disliked

And then the situation happens, and once I got there, completely changed my opinion on the book. Like, until then it was like a beach read, it was fun, a popcorn read, whatever. And then I found a situation, again, I can't tell you in the comment section, is just unacceptable.

Disliked

I feel like Fourth Wing, my main issue was that it just didn't make sense in multiple places. Again, I'm not going to spoil anything, but I will say that twice she and an important discussion while she's up a tree. Like how convenient can that be?

Mixed

I think the way that he written writes about the children's fears, it's so well written. You can feel it. Every disturbing scenes, again, he's a little too good sometimes at writing them, but then you have the scene, again, I'm going to be vague, the sewer scene.

Disliked

So, that's why I went into her books, I bought two. I bought The Housemaid and Never Lie, and I didn't finish Never Lie, but I did finish The Housemaid. And the whole time I was questioning my sanity because I'm not opposed to popcorn reads.

Disliked

And then he just proceeds to have some kind of sexual contact with every female character that crosses his path. And it's just terribly written. First of every spicy scene, the female characters are compared to babies or children.

Mixed

for example, I wasn't as invested as much as I wanted to for All the Light We Cannot See or even The Book Thief, which I picked it up mostly because the narration is told from Death's point of view, which I thought that was brilliant, but then I read it and I felt nothing.

Disliked

Like it's just constantly like female characters trying to make the male character not follow his life mission because they want to marry him and have his babies even though they're children. And then at the end, the main female character who went through a lot, she gets gang and then 2 days later, she meets the main male character and she has sex with him and tells him she loves him and want to have his babies and, you know, Are we being serious?

Disliked

And then book two just flopped completely after these first 300 pages. I'm not going to spoil anything in this video, but I can happily do it in the comment section. But there are like 10 chapters where everything goes sideway and I the author just loses me.

Disliked

How are you supposed to make me believe that you are a good assassin when you're just doing things like that? I felt like it was more about the love triangle than anything. Again, kind of a romantic-y more than fantasy.