Tier Ranking 10 Years of Favourites 🏆 (+ also Eyeballs & Book Club Reads)

A house at the bottom of Lake I have reread absolutely holds up as like my favorite horror Nolla

a little devil in America I think will go down as one of my favorite non-fictions

all her little secrets and Whisper down the lane and the devotion of suspect X because I remember in past year struggling with what tier they should be in because they weren't great but they weren't met

the last one is an academy for liars and unfortunately we've got the fourth one of 2024 in the wolf category... didn't go well for me and it didn't go well for the hosts... very ambitious and didn't meet its fullest potential

the book of the most precious substance so good so different so memorable

I don't think I standby Carry On the same way or the evolution of Mara

daughter of the Moon Goddess was a fantasy I loved

these are all such good books but not one of them is in the all-time favorites... death in her hands again not everybody's really into

dress coats for small towns is something I still consider an all-time favorite

Dune is in there Dune like the fact that I got to that and it was so good

Emily Wild's encyclopedia fairies is such an interesting one... I gave it a 4.5... I realized how much I loved it and then it ended up being like in my top three of the Year

me discovering every heart Ador that year but the thing at the time I only gave that a four which is so strange to think about now

Finley Donovan like this was so fun getting introduced to that type of mystery

which is girl made of stars because it's ya and I just don't feel like a lot of passion for those ones

not include girls burn brigher that's one I ultimately chose because I think it holds up more than the book I actually put in my number one position

gong girl made me fall in love with reading again

graveyard shift I don't need the new tier for this is going in woof... most of us were like this was a complete waste of time... it needed to be a novel it wasn't satisfying

House of leaves obviously is like in the top 10 of all time and it took me so long to finally read it and I'm so glad I did

how beautifully were was great at its time

I was a teenage slasher oh man so I want to put it in the top row because you know I gave it a five it's is it my favorite book of the year it's one of my favorite books of the year

same with I'll give you the sun I'll give you the sun I will be rereading soon which is very exciting

if we were villains like yeah it was a favorite at the time I think it's still a favorite now but it's not better than any of my other favorites from any other year

it was illumin I finally you guys convinced me to read illumin and it ended up being I think in my like top three maybe of that video I loved it so much

I loved Kindra

leech was really good

it was lock every door the turn of the key some of my favorite mystery books

middle of the night by Riley Sager is tough for me to remember because it was such a disappointment for me... it just didn't really do anything for us

monilia was so good and so many of us loveed this like weird literary horror

Mrs death was another one a weird one not everybody was into

my heart is a chainsaw by stepen grah Jones especially like when I find horror that not everybody meshes with but I love so much it just stands out even more in my mind

I don't think natural beauty and leech are like all-time favorites for me

the night guest I think was because it was everybody most people's favorite in the live show I in my mind want to put it into great but I think it was just comparatively overall most people thought it was a decent story

we had night watching by Tracy Sierra next and I'm debating between me and solid because in my mind it was a solid read it was just a fast-paced thriller... which hurt me because I liked it

nothing to see here was really interesting

we started out the year without there screaming now me nor my co-host was really a fan of this one but there's always going to be books in a collection that you love and that you hate

this one sister's Lost Nation I'm also going to put in meh and that's because of my own opinion and everybody else who was in the comments

all her little secrets and Whisper down the lane and the devotion of suspect X because I remember in past year struggling with what tier they should be in because they weren't great but they weren't met

I don't think I standby Carry On the same way or the evolution of Mara

I finally got to the fifth season absolutely held up the way that everybody said it would

then we had the god of the Woods by lizmore which is exactly what I pitched it to be a very slow literary mystery I would be putting it in iconic because the more I reflect on it I think it was such an interesting story

The Maro thieves is so good

I also read the Martian which I know I haven't reread but like obviously it holds up

The only good Indians I gave a four but because of everyone else's love for it just ends up in this in this tier but I think I have to put it down to solid... it made for a good discussion I think it was so unique and so interesting

I think I would move up the other people our very first ever book club read because it was a decent mystery and it deserves a little bit more respect

it was lock every door the turn of the key some of my favorite mystery books

the sky is everywhere I rad and loved

this is where we talk things about by kayn Marco this one I feel like more people liked than didn't I just thought it was okay

same with tin foil butterfly

maybe it was that one verer along I'm going to put in the very top category this is a mystery of a older woman who runs a tea shop and one day there's somebody dead... the writing is fun and I think the general consensus is that one was pretty iconic

we ride upon Sticks being here I think I'm going to have to put it in living my best life cuz it was just objectively a good time

all her little secrets and Whisper down the lane and the devotion of suspect X because I remember in past year struggling with what tier they should be in because they weren't great but they weren't met

the Wild Ones a ya fantasy I didn't expect to be in there but it was really good I don't think it's it's not an all-time favorite

you know what you did by KT nen is next and I gave it the same rating... many of us could and we ended up giving it a two or a three so that one is our first one of the year that's at the bottom