BooksandLala 163K subscribers · Apr 19, 2026

Trying to Find 5⭐ Horror from a Decade Ago

Reviews20

I'm going to give it three stars. The first quarter was really interesting. The second quarter was fine. The last half I was like, whatever. I do think this book balanced things well, and it was everything it set out to be. It just wasn't my perfect kind of horror.

with Disappearance at Devil's Rock, I'm equally as bored, but I'm interested in what the reveal is going to be. It's just not a very well-crafted mystery to me, but I want to know so desperately what happened to this little boy.

HexUnknown
Not a fan

I'm DNF'ing Hex. I'm so bored 150 pages in that I just can't imagine reading 200 more pages to get to what I don't think is a very interesting ending or story, just the vibes that I'm getting.

Horror MoviePaul Tremblay
Loved it

And then next is I don't know if it's Horror Movie or The Cabin at the End of the World... And then Horror Movie is more of an objective favorite.

ResurrectionUnknown
Mixed

At the end of it all, my final rating is a 31.5 divided amongst 10 stories, that makes it a 3.1. So, not even like contestable.

The Con SeasonAdam Cesare
Not a fan

Sadly, I have been struggling through this. I finished it and I don't really have much to say. I felt really unsatisfied and really uninterested in this book and everyone we were following.

The FishermanJohn Langan
Mixed

This just wasn't my perfect idea of a cosmic horror, nor my perfect idea of what a grief horror looks like. It did well in the folksy-ness of it, but folk horror isn't my favorite. It was good, it wasn't great.

Young SlasherS.L. Gray
Not a fan

So I read the first chapter, then I read the second chapter and I just don't think this is going to be the one for me. It did not do anything for me.