BooksandLala 163K subscribers · Nov 25, 2022

bookish tier ranking

Reviews9

Mixed

all her little secrets was about a lawyer woman and this like workplace Dynamic and then also murder though there was a mixed bag of ratings for this too I want to call it solid I think we had a lot of good conversations and people who didn't like it they came out of the live show understanding why other people loved it and getting like a different perspective on things

Loved

now we've got confessions and I think that was our first iconic it was definitely our first iconic pick of the year was it our only iconic pick of the year I can get into that was a Revenge kind of story a teacher giving a lecture to her students her young students a lot of wild stuff happened it was pretty ridiculous but I think iconic is where it actually has to go

Disliked

hide by Kirsten White I didn't like and I think there were some people who enjoyed it but I feel like I have to put it at the same level as the death of Jane Lawrence like those are kind of in my mind have the same kind of vibe as far as what the audience was feeling I think that if you love The Death of Jane Lawrence maybe hide is for you it's like an amusement park hide and seek game but it's also like Fantastical just a little bit so not good for me and I think average for the group

Loved

we've got the house across the lake which I feel like I should defend to my very core like I want people to understand how good this is but everyone's opinion is valid I feel like a lot of people would put it with survive the night right here and say that Riley Sager is just not for them Riley Sager is for me survive the night was a fluke I think overall I have to put it in math even though I loved it's about a woman who sees this couple across the lake that she thinks is bad for each other and then there's like a drowning that occurs a life-saving effort and then just a lot of like interesting Dynamics after

Liked

House of hunger which is about a girl who becomes a blood maid for this Rich affluent society I don't want to give away my rating yet and because we haven't had the discussion like it's hard to place it somewhere specific I'm gonna put it in solid though based on what I've seen from reviews on Instagram and the Goodreads chat and people in my DMs it's going well for a lot of people so if you've been considering picking it up I would say you're pretty safe in deciding to pick it up especially if you enjoyed the year of the Witch and I feel good about it being in solid

Mixed

it wasn't my favorite I feel like a lot of people would probably say to put it in iconic but because my rating was a little bit lower I feel like I have to meet it in the middle so I'm putting it in solid I think the discussion was great a lot of people really enjoyed it there was a lot of things to talk about

Mixed

The Paris apartment I feel like was kind of a mixed bag there were people who really enjoyed it I think I gave it between a two and a three this is about a woman who stays in her brother's Paris apartment there's a mystery to solve and there's a lot of perspectives I think it was interesting people had a lot of things to say but I don't think like anybody or many people like absolutely adored it

Liked

what moves the dead I thought this was fine but so many people loved it I think the top row is reserved for like high four stars and fives from me and Collective book club members loves so I'm going to put it in solid it was definitely fun reading and retelling it's a Gothic Story by Edgar Allan Poe originally there was lots to talk about

Liked

you're invited into solid because I think the majority of us had a lot of fun with this one as always there was a mix of ratings but this one about a girl going to her friend's wedding it had really fun like atmosphere there was different perspectives there was an added like interview segment and I think that overall most people would say it was a solid pick