when I read the Christmas carol I'm like what a genius idea and when I read the haunted man I'm like what a genius idea in a way that I just don't feel when I read the other three Christmas books
Reflections on The Haunted Man | Christmas Dickens Readalong
I do really like the trimes and the Battle of life and the Cricket on half but I do think like for me A Christmas Carol and the haunted man are like on a different level
I think the trimes definitely went up in my estimation on this reread and the cricket on the half went down. it's hard with the Chimes cuz I basically feel like both the cricket on the half and the Battle of Life probably execute what they're trying to do better but I just feel like what the Chimes is trying to do is more interesting
I was also thinking about how much I loved reading the Christmas hings by Mary Elizabeth Braden
my least favorite on this reread was the cricket on the heart which I think always used to be more in the middle but no that goes at the bottom this time
I think it's really atmospheric really clever really powerful it is one of dickens's Darker Christmas stories but for me I just think it's really strong. I think the premise and the themes are just really interesting and it's really well done and I love it a lot.





