I kept thinking as I was reading this about another book on the long list, Clear by Caris Davis. , which is a wonderful, wonderful book that is also in many ways about language and communication.
Final Thoughts on the Walter Scott Prize 2025
While I say Glorious Exploits is my favorite to win and it is my favorite to win because I loved it the most and I think it is incredible and just genuinely one of the best novels I've ever read and like I can't believe that was a debut. what a absolute masterpiece.
My second favorite from my personal short list is Maybe Mother Naked by Glenn James Brown because I did just think that was very fun and very clever.
The year News of the Dead by James Robertson won, that was the year it was my favorite to win, but this year it wasn't.
I thought it was really fascinating and very well crafted and I really like Andrew Miller as a writer, though I didn't love this one quite as much as And now I should be entirely free.
I think as a coming of age story it is wonderful. the characterization is so rich.
It's one of those books that has a lot of big themes explored through everyday life and small moments which I really loved.
I did also really love the land in winter by Andrew Miller, but I just feel like The Mayor is a really like very hard-hitting but very important thematically vital book about how ordinary people who might never do evil things in certain circumstances might do horrendously evil things in particular social and political contexts.
I thought it was just a great really tense really thematically fascinating novel with fantastic characterization.
I don't think The Book of Days will win because I think it is a quieter, more ponderous novel and I think it's very well done. , I think it works very, very effectively, but I don't think it's necessarily packs the punch of some of the others.








