Books and Things 39K subscribers · Jun 28, 2021

Walter Scott Prize - Reviews & Winner Thoughts

Reviews5

Liked

i did really enjoy it i did like it as a novel but i do think it was a standout for me as the other three books were and i felt like the kind of pacing and the structure of it wasn't always quite right for me and i would have preferred the focus to be in slightly different places

Liked

this was in some ways a really interesting novel i really enjoyed the kind of central relationship between hamza and afiya especially when it kind of comes into its own in the second half of the novel and i found the way it looked at the kind of impact of colonialism and the first world war on this community really interesting

Loved

i did find it moving but i think actually i found it more interesting and readable and kind of powerful and then moving like for me hammond it was a book about family more than a book about grief and so i loved it i did but i don't think i loved it quite as much as lots of other people loved it

Loved

it just has an amazing scope and it's just fantastic and beautifully written and it's filled with a love of words and language and it's all about gender and kind of how certain words are valued about others and often because they're sort of more male words and it's just fantastic and fascinating and i just adored the dictionary of lost words so much