I found them quite hit and miss so I think my favorites were probably a book for Christmas
December Reading Wrap Up
the haunted man is the best of these three and the second best of Charles diggin' Christmas Devas after A Christmas Carol
this is a really fascinating book and I'm very glad that I read it and I'm sure I will come back to bits of it in the future it's not an easy read like it's quite dense and quite dry in places and basically I would say that Henry May's writing style isn't that exciting
the characterization is incredible the writing is amazing it is one of those books that is so serious and like profound and Powerful but also has moment of like real humor and joy
I really like the Battle of life I would say that like the central plot and the central characters are not necessarily the most exciting thing ever but the minor characters in the Battle of Life are amazing
it was so fantastic genuinely one of my favorite Classics of the year
the cricket on the half has some really nice moments but I have to say that I enjoyed it a lot less on this reread than I have done previously
I love the haunted man so much and I really recommend it probably next Christmas rather than in January but it is really fantastic I promise
overall I thought this collection was good there were two stories in it that were like five stars for me and then the others were less strong and there were some that I definitely liked quite a lot less
it's such a beautiful joyous book about like celebrating happiness and things that make you happy both big things and Tiny things and it's just lovely
The twists and turns of the plot were very well done and it was really compelling like it's quite a long book and I read it in a couple of days over Christmas and just really enjoyed it










